Nick, I know you researched this, and its best to find things out for yourself, but you should look up the BB federation that Vice McMahon started, and he got Mauro DiPasquale to create diets for all the top IFBB pros that defected.
they were sooooooo fat on the AD diet that they used props to cover all the fat during the posing. They all quickly left and Weider fined them massive numbers, they had to pay to get back in.
In the 30 years I've followed BB, I've never read of a single pro EVER following this unbelievably unhealthy diet.
Now you know I've tried it, and stayed on it for around 8-10 weeks.
Yes I lost body fat. Yes I was unhealthier. Yes I was weaker.
Talking to a National Level BB here in Canada, I picked his brains.
He eats exactly the same foods everyday. Chicken, rice, vegies, panckes, protein drinks.
4500 calories to gain, 2500 when cutting.
This is the healthiest long term approach ever used. The AD diet is just another fad.
For quick fat loss, only the velocity diet is superior, so it will work for that, but long term? You looked pretty good to me following a basic approach that works for anyone with discipline.
Does anyone you hang with or train with have a better physique than you?
Do you really think eliminating fruit for 5 days a week is smart?