Sounds like he was after some input from you. Maybe you should have asked him more about what he was doing. Could have been looking for guidance or change of routine.
I was paraphrasing the conversation. He didn't want detailed feedback. He just had this odd thing where he wanted to openly admit he was ignoring everything I'd told him.
The Hamburgler said:
Sounds like some of the guys involved in the AFL.
They have some odd ideas. I was talking to a trainer involved with them. He was doing half squats.
"Don't you want full range of motion to strengthen glutes and hams, reduce chance of hamstring injury?"
"Oh no we do stuff like this," he said demonstrating. Lay down in front of the cable machine, put a strap on his heel, stretched out his leg and did a really slow hip extension/flexion.
Seemed silly to me, but I always say:
results count. Do teams who abandon deep squats and replace them with half squats and slow cable hip extensions (a) have less hammie pulls and (b) win games more often? If the answer to both is "yes", it's a good idea. If the answer is, "well, it depends..." then probably not.
I wouldn't claim to know either way. Despite what they told us at PT school, most of us will never work with top athletes.
Theory's great, we can learn a lot. But what about results? One of my clients told me another trainer had said you shouldn't hold your breath during squats and deadlifts, you risk injury. I asked, "Do this trainer's clients squat or deadlift more than their bodyweight on the bar?"
"Not even that. Half squats and stuff."
"So that is the result of that trainer's advice. No-one is injured, no-one gets strong."
"I guess. I want to be strong, but I don't want to get injured."
"Ask the other trainer if they can name a healthy person who was injured holding their breath, or where some trainer got sued successfully because of their advice on holding your breath while lifting heavy."
Hasn't got back to me, so I assume the answer is "no-one."
I would ask the visiting clipboard guy if the teams he's advised have (a) lowered incidence of injury and (b) won more games. If so, all good. If not, thanks, bye.
Results count. This is why I don't give PT business advice
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/a0dd6/a0dd67a17ec8b6e6bcb45d7047f3d9bfe87084bb" alt="Smile :) :)"