Of course Markos went to stronglifts.com to stir, he stirs everywhere he goes, all forums, his newsletters, his garage... I've never sat down to dinner with his family, but I bet he stirs them, too! So he's not picking on Mehdi
Mehdi is no comfortable being challenged in any way by other people, see
this thread here.
fsaekar said:
I'm just thankful I found SL.com before it became an ad-fest for fasting and now psychological self-help. A lot of the articles here are golden, and its Mehdi's bluntness about building muscle and losing fat that attracted me and probably 99% of the faithful here at SL.com. [...]
Here's to hoping that in 2010 SL.com stays true to its roots. Careful, Mehdi---we know you'd love to double your income again this year but it could come at a different kind of cost.
I think he is spot-on. But Mehdi didn't like that, and did not reply to any substantive point, basically told him to fck off
I think stronglifts is a good programme for a novice training on their own without anyone to coach them, though doing 5 sets rather than 3 sets will lead to earlier stalls in progression. I don't think it's a good programme if you have a trainer or traning partner, you can do better things with someone else there to help you.
I wouldn't pay $347 a month to exchange videos with someone and hear their wacky ideas about fasting and self-help. But then I am sceptical of all online training, to really work with someone you have to be there. You can do some stuff, but it's limited.
His forum is useful to read, if only because some ordinary people have got relatively strong, and record it in their journals. As Markos says, a good number of them know more about lifting, diet and so on than the site owner. Good to read, not much reason to write in it, though.