Great thread guys. Some points that stuck out at me:
The correctional goals of the criminal justice system are retribution, restitution, incapacitation, rehabilitation and deterrence...
...Capital punishment costs more than life in prison.
I'm interested how the courts fit all this into some of the prison sentences I've seen...
Also, re the death penalty, that also hasnt worked in the past plus you run the risk of killing innocent people. Hundreds of people have been exonerated from death row in the USA and there are examples of people being found innocent after years in prison for crimes that would carry the death penalty it it were still in operation in Australia.
Having said that, I have never seen someone go into life imprisonment for a first offence. Usually its suspended sentence or something similar. I figure if the person gets a death penalty it is the result of a life of crime, and the final straw, whether they are 'exonerated' later or not, is not so important.
Lifting weights is a good way to learn respect, dedication, discipline, effort etc and the rewards could go a long way towards rehabilitation.
Agree with this.
They get anything they bloody want. I f they dont want to work in there they dont bloody have to, they can sit around watching tv, playing playstation, tennis, footy, weight training, boxing.
He is right unfortunately. Especially with Juveniles. The courts go easy on these lads (usually due to their upbringing and other points raised by leachy) but the quickly discover incarcertaion is better than living at home. So it is no longer a deterrent. Swimming pools, basketball courts, plus you get to see all your mates! More like a holiday home.
...Tell me how that works.
Sorry to hear your story mate. I think on the scale of things the system is broken and anyone middle and upper class are happy to leave it like that. Unfortunately some stories like yours do happen, and the ones who do deserve prison get so many chances it makes me sick.
All in all though, I think someone on this thread put it best when they said the gym should be a reward for working hard. Just like swimming pools, internet, magazines etc. should all be rewards. If you don't want to work, you aren't prepared to 'rehabilitate'. Bread and water. If you want to develop a good working attitute then you will be rewarded.
I think the attitudes some of them hold start at an early age where they get no rewards. They have to look after themselves, and have no responsible person to really instill the 'worker' in them. Its so much easier just to not work, get handed welfare and steal what else you want. Especially if the court only gives you a slap on the wrist because you are 'too young'!