I'll post this speaking from personal opinion here and not for the company.
Take of this what you will as I'm sure it will be hard to see through posting from the company account.
I, myself, Nick, love the Choc Mint personally. Our first go of this was absolutely shithouse though. Bloody hell, even I drilled into Ben about it. It was mouthwash. Mint, yes, but the wrong type. There's mouth wash mint or there's dessert type mint.
We switched to the correct type after this mistake and we have only had mostly positive reviews. So much so now that the description of this from customers on our Facebook page is "liquid Mint Slice biscuits." I have got to agree. Even similarly to those Aero choc mint bars.
Cookie's and Cream should have been named Scotch Finger biscuits. This is the nickname given to this now from customers. Very similar from smell to taste.
However, I do not like our Strawberry and don't like our Vanilla.
No taste buds are the same. To me it is ridiculous that no one would like our Choc Mint as I can't personally fault it but then we have regular buyers of our Vanilla (top of the list seller with Chocolate) and also our Strawberry and I think that THEY are insane! lol.
The beauty of opinions and tastes I guess.