Is your BTN press strict? What grip width do you use?
I know this is focusing on the minor details but it's always interdasting to see
Yep strict. BTN press is my favorite upper body lift now. Close grip just outside shoulder width.
I've been doing those Klokov presses. It's basically a snatch grip strict BTN press. There is a video of klokov doing 110kg for an easy triple lol. My best is like 30kg and it feels like my neck is about to explode. I imagine that if you got really good at them, you'd see improvement in everything, simply because they are such a damn hard lift
Just be careful with this mate, it's an awesome exercises but few people can do it full ROM without causing problems either now or later down the track. Stopping at the top of the head would be considere "safe" ROM for everyone.
Yep everyone says that but I doubt many of them have actually done the exercise for any length of time. Doing BTN presses are easier on my shoulders than any benching and my shoulders feel better after doing them. Sure some people will have problems with them, like any exercise, but I don't see how they are anywhere near as dangerous as people think. I would guess low bar squats and bench cause as many or more problems for people's shoulders as BTN presses.
Doing them to the top of the head would be pretty pointless in my opion.
Regarding speed bench - I just think that doing reps would work better for a raw bencher
Doing 10x3x60% is not the only way to increase speed-strength. One look at the videos of Sheiko's lifters will show you this
IIRC, Ryan Kennelly will start his bench workout with a shit load of reps (and the bar moves FAST) working up to 405lb for 20 reps raw (yeah) and will then max out his raw bench before going to shirted board presses and finishing with arms + back. I didn't see any speed benching at all in his "Road to the Arnold" video, just lots of rep work with the bar moving astonishingly fast
I think the practising form obviously holds merit but for a raw bencher I just don't see speed bench having a significant carry over to your 1RM. I think Chad Wesley-Smith has openly said speed work is pointless for a raw lifter (he definitely said it about box squats)
Yep saw that video a while ago. I've given them a go once or twice but nothing serious yet. They are tough.
Yep everyone says that but I doubt many of them have actually done the exercise for any length of time. Doing BTN presses are easier on my shoulders than any benching and my shoulders feel better after doing them. Sure some people will have problems with them, like any exercise, but I don't see how they are anywhere near as dangerous as people think. I would guess low bar squats and bench cause as many or more problems for people's shoulders as BTN presses.
Doing them to the top of the head would be pretty pointless in my opion.
I never said its the only way, its just one of many. But when comparing to other bench specialist programs like Sheiko and Smolov Jr your not devoting most of your training time to bench. Speed-Strength is moving sub-maximal weights with maximal velocity and speed bench fits this description. Have you ever done speed work? Saying "I think" its better has no merit.
I love it when people bring up Kennelly for speed benching because hes a proponent of it for raw benchers. Ive got a link to an interview that I cant find right now but he says "1 heavy day and 1 speed day with 8x3 @60%". Paraprased but still. Also "Road to the Arnold" if Im not mistaken was contest prep, not 100 on that, but the type of training can be different leading to contest. But then look at Dave Hoff with a 945lb bench, he does speed bench. But I do remember watching that 405 x 20, fuck that was beast.
Now Chad Wesley-Smith is doing well with his Juggernaut method but openly saying something doesnt make it true. Box squats can definitely ruin form if the the lifter doesnt keep up his raw squatting technique. The two are completely different lifts.
Sheiko isn't a bench specialist program. I was just commenting on what I have seen. Kennelly is a geared bencher and I was talking about the benefits of speed benching for a raw bencher and used Kennelly as an example of someone who did very little speed benching and don't know the ins and outs of his training, just that I didn't see any speed benching in his videos, only reps. I'd like to see that interview if you can find it
Also for the record, when talking about "speed bench" I am referring to westside style speed benching where you do something like 10x3x60%. As I said before there are lots of different ways to increase speed-strength other than speed benching but I don't think increasing speed-strength is all that important for the raw lifter and that most people would get better use out of doing reps on their lighter day (if they follow westside template just as an example) to get better at grinding out a weight. Defranco also thinks this way regarding speed bench, although he is a big fan of box squatting but I suspect that is because it makes them faster in their sports rather than their squatting specifically
Man, they are great. I've been doing them a bit lately on delts day - huge fun. I'm really only pressing like 40kg when doing them, but they work my rear and side delts like nobodies business.
I get absolutely no (short term) ill effects from BTN Pressing (keep in mind I've only ever done BTN standing or on a smith - never seated). For a solid few months though, my routine was DB/BB/Smith Presses to the front, side lateral raises then BTN presses on a smith.
I like you Rian I really do but if you mention smith machines in this thread again I am going to have to ask you to leave.
I liken the smith machine to a porno yeah its interesting, but no matter how many times you watch it it's still not the same as fucking.
Sorry your right, Sheiko is not a Bench specialist program but I it would be classed as a specialist program as a whole. Now you're commenting on what you have ACTUALLY seen or experienced in person or commemnting on stuff said in forums??
As a whole, Conjugated Periodisation (westside programmimg), did not take into account for the development of geared lifting many years after it was originally thought up by the Dynamo Club.
If you don't know the in's and out of something why are you referencing it? Because you saw a video? And then using a geared lifter to reference raw lifting doesnt make sense.
For the record, I know what you mean by speed benching. Again you "think" speed strength isnt important, how have you come to this conclusion? Yes in the Westside template you could call it a "lighter" day, but it is still very challenging to put 100% effort into sub max weights. Max effort work is there to increase the ability to grind against weights 90% and above, thats what it is. So adding rep work as main work changes it and it is no longer Westside anymore. Its WS4SB by Joe Defranco. Now Joe Defranco took the Conjugate Method (Consisting of the Max effort, Dynamic Effort and Repeated Effort Methods) and shaped it to his own needs when training athletes. Athletes are not lifters and only doing what they need to do to be better at their sport. Thus why the DE Lower day is still in the mix, but with bodyweight movements for the most part.
You're right, we should never look to successful people and at what they are doing, figure everything out for ourselves but certainly never think
He's good at that, really good.Great response bro, way to avoid all that I mentioned and make some complete bullshit up that has nothing to do with what I said.