• Keep up to date with Ausbb via Twitter and Facebook. Please add us!
  • Join the Ausbb - Australian BodyBuilding forum

    If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact contact us.

    The Ausbb - Australian BodyBuilding forum is dedicated to no nonsense muscle and strength building. If you need advice that works, you have come to the right place. This forum focuses on building strength and muscle using the basics. You will also find that the Ausbb- Australian Bodybuilding Forum stresses encouragement and respect. Trolls and name calling are not allowed here. No matter what your personal goals are, you will be given effective advice that produces results.

    Please consider registering. It takes 30 seconds, and will allow you to get the most out of the forum.

Weightlifting to introduce video technology after Glasgow 2014 controversy

Admin

Administrator. Graeme
Staff member
Weightlifting is to introduce video technology after a series of controversial results in recent international competitions.

This comes after potential winners at the Athens 2004 Olympic Games and this year's Commonwealth Games in Glasgow were denied gold medals by judging errors, while disputes have also occurred at the recent Asian Games in Incheon and other major events.

Three cameras will be used, positioned to give views from the judges' line of sight, and when video evidence is needed, it will be used quickly.

The cameras will be used from next year, when the first international competition is the International Weightlifting Federation (IWF) Youth World Championships in Lima, Peru, in April.

The move is similar to that taken by FIFA when, at this year's World Cup, they accepted the use of cameras to determine whether the ball had crossed the goalline.

In other changes, the IWF has adopted a new logo to modernise its corporate identity, and has agreed to spend more than one fifth of its annual budget on anti-doping measures.

The latest judging error, in an otherwise highly successful weightlifting programme at Glasgow 2014 in July, cost Australian Simplice Ribouem a gold medal.

Australia's Simplice Ribouem was denied a gold medal at Glasgow 2014 because of a judging error ©Getty Images

Steven Kari, from Papua New Guinea, touched his knee with his elbow during his last, decisive lift, making it illegal.

The attempt was originally declared a no-lift, leaving Ribouem in first place, but after a review the jury of appeal reversed that decision, declared the lift good, and gave gold to Kari.

Television pictures later found this was the wrong decision, but under current rules, officials had no access to them, so it remained unchanged.

Ribouem said after the medal ceremony, "I'm upset.

"He [Kari] knows that already, but he's not a judge.

"You can't do anything.

"The judges decide."

An even bigger controversy came at Athens 2004, in the women's super-heavyweight class.

South Korea's Jang Mi-ran was left disappointed by a judging decision at the 2004 Olympics in Athens ©Getty Images


South Korea's Jang Mi-ran, the future Olympic champion in Beijing, was left in second place when a clean-and-jerk world record attempt by Tang Gonghong, of China, was approved by the judges.

It was considered a poor decision, as Tang was not fully in control of the bar, nor static.

Sam Coffa, vice-president of the IWF and chairman of its technical committee, has now declared that "enough is enough".

"I used to be against the use of video technology, but now I'm convinced it's a necessity," he announced during the IWF Congress in Almaty, held alongside the World Championships which ended yesterday in the Kazakhstan city.

"I have seen gold medals being awarded to the wrong athlete, and that decision in Glasgow was atrocious.

"There is too much human error."

Delegates were also told of encouraging figures in the fight against doping.

The number of banned athletes in 2013 was a very disappointing 97, from around 2,000 tests.

To date in 2014 the number of tests is about the same pro rata - 1,700 in 10 months - but only 17 have returned positive.

Last year a total of 18 lifters from Azerbaijan alone were banned.

The IWF approved a budget in which nearly $1.5 million (£2.3 million/€1.9 million) - 21 per cent of income - was set aside for tackling doping.



http://www.insidethegames.biz/sports/summer/weightlifting/1023728-exclusive-weightlifting-to-introduce-video-technology-after-glasgow-2014-controversy
 
It's an interesting dilemma - rely on experts eye or scrutinise lifts for half an hour before declaring good or not.
 
The commentators have access to instant play back. I guess it just got too embarrassing for the judges to have an obvious no lift being run and re run for the TV audience, then the judges coming out after a review and saying, "all good". Not sure what the issue with not using it was.

Maybe one day it will be used in powerlifting. :cool:
 
Top