nurse tells bodybuilder she must lose weight and exercise more

Date: 26 March 2014nA female bodybuilder has slammed an NHS nurse who branded her overweight and told her she needed to exercise more and eat less.nAthletic Anita Albrecht (Pictured) was left stunned when a nurse told her she was ¿eating too much¿ and needed to go on a drastic diet to lose weight during a routine appointment. A superfit bodybuilder was branded overweight and put on a strict diet by an NHS nurse simply based on her BMI.
Anita Albrecht said she was told during a routine appointment she was ‘eating too much’ and needed to lose weight.
The 39-year-old, who works as a personal trainer, said her body mass index came out at 29 – four points over the healthy range and one short of obese.
But Ms Albrecht, who competes against some of the world’s leading bodybuilders, said the measure was distorted by her muscle-bound physique.
She said: ‘She insulted me by making assumptions about my lifestyle.
‘The information the nurse has given me is actually dangerous. A 1,000 calorie-a-day diet is only for people who are severely obese who are not active.
‘They should only be on that for a maximum of 12 weeks – generally as a precursor to surgery.’
BMI is worked out by dividing weight in kilograms by height in metres squared. But critics say it is flawed because it does not distinguish between fat and muscle, which is heavier.
Miss Albrecht, who is 1.5m (4ft 11in) tall and weighs about 66kg (10st), saw the nurse during an appointment about contraception at a family planning clinic in Harold Hill, east London.
She was told she needed to exercise more, eat less and to cut alcohol and fruit juice from her diet.
‘She put me on scales and clearly I’m a lot heavier than other women because of my height and I’m a bodybuilder,’ said Miss Albrecht.
‘For nine months of the year I don’t even drink as I am a competitive athlete. I felt insulted, was made to feel as though I was overweight, over eating and I felt a knock in my confidence.
‘When I tried to explain to her about body composition she wasn’t interested at all.’
NHS England declined to comment because of patient confidentiality. But its website concedes that athletes, such as rugby players, can be wrongly classed as overweight using BMI.
Body Mass Index is calculated by dividing a person’s weight in kilograms by their height in metres squared.
The measurement was devised by Belgian mathematician Adolphe Quetelet while studying astronomy in 19th century France.
The student was inspired by stargazers who used probability to make their measurements as accurate as possible and decided to apply the same techniques to human features.
However, it wasn’t until the 1970s that researchers re-visited and supported his ‘Quetelet Index’ formula.

Retard medical people are gonna retard, any reasonable person can see she in a great shape

Dunno about over there, but here nurses wouldn't be giving such advice for starters, especially not specifics like that.

Omg she's hot!!!

My BMI says Im overweight. My jean size says the opposite.

My BMI says I'm overweight, my flabby gut agrees...

I've basically been the same weight for 10 years or so but body composition has obviously changed through that time. If my bmi remains steady am I not getting healthier? I have jeans that were too long because I needed the width and now they're too wide and too long.

Maybe the nurse needs to get an appointment with the optometrist.

When I see my doctor, you have to see the nurse before going in. She takes waist measurements, weigjt and BP and tells you how fat you are.
She always makes comment about how inaccurate the BMI system is and just says the waist measurement is the important one and dont let it grow

I thought BF% was more important than BMI

kaz said:

When I see my doctor, you have to see the nurse before going in. She takes waist measurements, weigjt and BP and tells you how fat you are.
She always makes comment about how inaccurate the BMI system is and just says the waist measurement is the important one and dont let it grow

Click to expand...

That's odd - my GP does that as part of the consultation.

BMI is meant to be fairly accurate amongst populations, obviously those packing muscle are outliers.

Headley said:

I thought BF% was more important than BMI

Click to expand...

Of course it is but you can't calculate that easily so someone made the bmi so they can label people as overweight easily. I have a mate who was telling me how low his bmi is and I just told him he looks malnourished not fit.

At 20% bodyfat my bmi was in the higher end of the normal range. BMI doesn't take into account large boobs....

BMI still has some places in medicine.

in Sleep Apnoea, it doesn't discriminate between fat or muscle, being heavy gives a higher % of risk. infact if your male, the heavier you are, the more sleep apnoea you have, FACT.

So atm heart disease is the no1 killer, and sleep has a huge correlation to heart disease.

I can see how bodybuilders ARE an unhealthy weight (self included). not compared to a fatty, compared to the starving human we were designed to be, before unlimited feeding was available.

BMI is accurate over large populations. It's never going to be perfect for individuals.